Rather than mimic Charles, Yarosh channeled the song through his own lens—warm, expressive, and sincere—imbuing every phrase with personal emotion and a sense of deep connection to the music.

Fortin, known for his signature swagger and vocal grit, brought a raw, authentic energy to the lead vocals. His delivery balanced rock-star attitude with theatrical precision, channeling the angst and longing of the song’s lovelorn narrator while also winking at its over-the-top dramatics.

Opening with Smith’s smooth and inviting vocals, the song began with the familiar melody—but this version had a fresh sense of momentum and brightness that hinted at the energy still to come. Yarosh joined soon after, bringing a warm, emotional timbre that complemented Smith’s tone perfectly. Together, they traded verses and harmonized with ease, offering a grounded, emotionally rich take on the lyrics that felt both nostalgic and newly resonant.